AUSTRALIA’S INTERNATIONAL CYBER ENGAGEMENT STRATEGY
Annex A: Australia’s position on how
international law applies to state conduct
in cyberspace
Existing international law provides
the framework for state behaviour
in cyberspace. This includes, where
applicable, the law regarding the use
of force, international humanitarian
law (IHL), international human rights
law, and international law regarding
state responsibility.
In this respect, Australia notes that the
centrality of international law and its
application to states’ use of cyberspace
was affirmed in 2013 in the consensus
report of the third United Nations Group
of Governmental Experts (UNGGE) on
Developments in the Field of Information
and Telecommunications in the Context
of International Security, which was
chaired by Australia, and reaffirmed in
the 2015 report of the UNGGE.
However, Australia recognises that
activities conducted in cyberspace raise
new challenges for the application of
international law, including issues of
sovereignty, attribution and jurisdiction,
given that different actors engage in
a range of cyber activities which may
cross multiple national borders. This
annex sets out Australia’s views on
these issues.
1. The United Nations Charter and
the law on the use of force (jus ad
bellum) apply to activities conducted
in cyberspace.
90
The Charter of the United Nations
requires states to seek peaceful
settlements of disputes. This obligation
extends to cyberspace and requires
states to resolve cyber incidents
peacefully without escalation or resort
to the threat or use of force. This
requirement does not impinge upon a
state’s inherent right to act in individual
or collective self-defence in response to
an armed attack, which applies equally
in the cyber domain as it does in the
physical realm.
In determining whether a cyber attack,
or any other cyber activity, constitutes
a use of force, states should consider
whether the activity’s scale and effects
are comparable to traditional kinetic
operations that rise to the level of use
of force under international law. This
involves a consideration of the intended
or reasonably expected direct and
indirect consequences of the cyber
attack, including for example whether
the cyber activity could reasonably be
expected to cause serious or extensive
(‘scale’) damage or destruction (‘effects’)
to life, or injury or death to persons, or
result in damage to the victim state’s
objects, critical infrastructure and/
or functioning.
2. For cyber operations constituting
or occurring within the context of an
international or non-international armed
conflict, the relevant international
humanitarian law (jus in bello) will apply
to the conduct of these cyber activities.
International humanitarian law (IHL)
(including the principles of humanity,
necessity, proportionality and
distinction) applies to cyber operations
within an armed conflict.
The IHL principle of proportionality
prohibits the launching of an attack
which may be expected to cause
incidental loss of civilian life, injury to
civilians, damage to civilian objects, or
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents