4 For Russia’s aggression against Ukraine, Russia has had to pay a high price not only because Ukraine itself strongly resists Russia’s aggression but also because the international community is imposing strong coordinated sanctions against Russia and continues to support Ukraine. In addition, European countries stand more united against Russian threats, and the European security environment is at a major turning point in the wake of Russia’s aggression against Ukraine. Clearly, the aggression by Russia, which has seen NATO’s 8 See Chapter 2 Chapter 3, Section 5-3-1 (Nuclear Forces) Chapter 3, Section 5-4 (Russian Forces in Japan’s Northern Territories) The Impact of the Russia’s Aggression against Ukraine on International Affairs and Various Countries’ Responses to It 1 General Situation 7 Russia has put importance on the role of military power and has sought to secure its powerful voice in the international community against the backdrop of the military power, but huge losses through its aggression against Ukraine will likely bring a decline of its power in medium- to long-term as well as changes of the military balances in surrounding areas.8 In particular, Russia may not only further seek to maintain and secure its influence on regions comprising the Collective Security Treaty Organization (CSTO), such as Belarus and Kazakhstan, but also further deepen its relations with China, which is considered to have something in common in terms of security, including countering the United States. In addition, Russia may further increase its emphasis on nuclear forces as a deterrent power until it recovers from the damage of its conventional forces from its invasion of Ukraine. If this happens, in the area surrounding Japan, the Russian military may further increase its activities around the Sea of Okhotsk, near the Northern Territories of Japan and the Chishima Islands, where its strategic nuclear-powered submarines constituting an important part of Russia’s strategic nuclear capability are operating. Russia’s Aggression against Ukraine that the AFRF suffered huge losses7 because they did not concentrate ground troops on particular fronts and conducted piecemeal deployments to multiple fronts, which caused some to question the Russian military’s operational capability in a large-scale war. In addition, it is considered that Russian cyber attacks and electronic warfare have not been as effective as initially expected. It is also conceivable that the so-called hybrid warfare instruments, such as false flag campaign and disinformation, focused on making it difficult to identify true actors, justifying their actions, and sending out disturbing information, have not worked well not only because the nature of these instruments is not consistent with a full-scale invasion using large-scale forces which cannot hide true actors, but also because Russia’s intentions were made public widely through active intelligence disclosures by the United States and the United Kingdom. On the other hand, Ukraine is acquiring huge external assistance from not only state governments but also private entities through its proactive information dissemination by key government leaders including Mr. Fedorov, Vice Prime Minister. The Ukrainian government also got ahead of Russia in fields such as intelligence, media, and cyberspace by recruiting volunteers to organize an “IT Army” whose main duty is to conduct cyber attacks against Russia.  eastward expansion as a threat to itself, catalyzed European countries to shift their security policies in this manner. Therefore, it is doubtful to say that Russia’s strategic objective of ensuring its own security through maintaining its “sphere of influence” has been achieved by the aggression. In this regard, based on the recognition that the security of Europe and that of the Indo-Pacific region including Eastern Asia are indivisible, Japan needs to pay attention to the future developments of the situation in Europe, including its strategic effects. This is because Japan is a close ally of the United States, a NATO member state, and For Russian military losses, Russia suffered 23,500 deaths according to an announcement by Ukraine’s General Staff Office on May 1, 2022. On the other hand, the Russian Ministry of Defense announced 1,351 had been killed and 3,825 left wounded on March 25 of the same year. For casualties on the Ukrainian side, President Zelenskyy said on April 16 of the same year that 2,500 to 3,000 were killed in combat and approximately 10,000 were left wounded. On April 25, 2022, US Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin said that Russia had failed to achieve its principal aim to totally subjugate Ukraine and that the Russia had already lost a lot of military capability. In addition, on May 2 of the same year, the UK Ministry of Defence announced its analyses, saying that although Russia had deployed forces equivalent to approximately 65% of all its entire ground combat strength at the initial phase of the aggression against Ukraine, more than quarter of these units might be rendered combat ineffective. Furthermore, UK Ministry of Defence indicated that some of Russia’s most elite units, including airborne forces had suffered the highest levels of attrition and it would probably take years for Russia to rebuild these forces. DEFENSE WHITE PAPER 14

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents