Part I
Security Environment Surrounding Japan
2
How Russia’s Aggression Started, What Triggered It, and What Factors Are Involved in It
1 Security Environment in Europe after
the End of the Cold War and Ukraine
(1) Building International Consensus on Ukraine’s
Territorial Integrity and Non-nuclear Status
The security environment in Europe was hugely transformed
by regime changes in Eastern European countries in and
after 1989, the end of the Cold War by the Malta Summit in
December of the same year, and the collapse of the Soviet
Union in 1991. This resolved the military confrontation
between the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO)
and the Warsaw Treaty Organization (WTO), which led to
the reduction of the danger of a large-scale war. But new
problems subsequently emerged, such as the intensification
of ethnic separation and independence issues—the
Yugoslav conflict, the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict, and the
Chechen conflict, which started around the collapse of the
Soviet Union—and concern about the proliferation of the
former Soviet Union’s weapons of mass destruction.
Ukraine, which demonstrated willingness to be
independent in a referendum in December 1991, played
an important role in the process of the dissolution of the
Soviet Union along with Russia and Belarus. The breaking
up of the Soviet Union was determined with the founding
declaration of the Commonwealth of Independent States
(CIS) by the three states in the same month.
There were issues over the sovereignty of the Crimean
Peninsula in southern Ukraine and about which country
the Black Sea Fleet, mainly based at Sevastopol on the
peninsula, belongs to between Ukraine and Russia,
which became independent states. In 1997, the two
countries agreed in principle on dividing the fleet and
recognizing Russia’s use of the base for 20 years and
also signed a treaty of amity and cooperation confirming
Ukraine’s territorial integrity and the inviolability of
both countries’ borders.
On the other hand, the management of nuclear
weapons inherited from the former Soviet Union such
as Intercontinental Ballistic Missiles (ICBM) and
strategic bombers became an issue in Ukraine, Belarus
and Kazakhstan. In 1992, Ukraine signed the Lisbon
Protocol for the Strategic Arms Reduction Treaty
(START I) together with Russia, Belarus, Kazakhstan,
Chapter
2
Russia’s Aggression against Ukraine
1
7
and the United States and agreed on becoming a
signatory to START I and on joining the Treaty on the
Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons (NPT) as a nonnuclear country. This agreement meant that Ukraine
would remove all its nuclear arsenal within its territory
together with Belarus and Kazakhstan and transfer
the control of it to Russia. The nuclear arsenal within
Ukraine was incorporated into the command structure
of the former Soviet Armed Forces, controlled from
Moscow, and Ukraine had no operational capability
of its own. But in the process of abolishing nuclear
weapons, Ukraine called for its security assurances
and economic assistance in exchange for the removal
of nuclear arsenal. Regarding the security assurances
for Ukraine, Russia, the United States, and the United
Kingdom signed the Budapest Memorandum on Security
Assurances in 1993. For economic assistance, various
kinds of assistance were provided as part of support
for dismantling and abolishing nuclear weapons in
former Soviet states, provided mainly by G7 countries,
including Japan. In 1996, all the nuclear arsenal in
Ukraine was transferred to Russia, which means that
Ukraine became a non-nuclear state.1
(2) Ukraine and Relations between Russia and NATO
Following the collapse of the Soviet Union, Central and
Eastern European countries such as Poland and Czech
Republic hoped to join NATO with the perspective of
securing their independence and security considering
their own historical background, and to participate in
European integration. NATO showed a negative attitude
towards Central and Eastern European countries joining
the alliance immediately, however, with emphasis on
cooperation with Russia. In 1994, NATO announced
the Partnership for Peace (PfP) as a new framework
of cooperation. Ukraine as well as other Central and
Eastern European countries participated in the PfP ahead
of other former Soviet states in terms of promoting
cooperation with NATO and maintaining its neutrality,
and Russia also participated in the framework.
In 1999, Poland, Czech Republic, and Hungary, which
improved their interoperability with NATO, joined the
alliance based on the PfP, which marked the beginning
The delivery of tactical nuclear weapons to Russia was completed by May 1992. Strategic nuclear weapons—SS-19 (130) and SS-24 (46)—are deployed in Ukraine and their delivery to Russia
was completed by June 1996. In addition, the control of strategic bombers, a vehicle of transporting nuclear weapons, was also transferred to the Ukraine Air Force Long-range Aviation Group
and all of their use was abolished.
DEFENSE OF JAPAN 2022
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents